When Should You Get a New Transmission?

Your car’s transmission is one of the most crucial components of your vehicle, responsible for transferring power from the engine to the wheels. When it starts failing, you may face difficult decisions—should you repair it, rebuild it, or replace it altogether? Understanding the signs of a failing transmission and knowing when to invest in a new one can save you from costly repairs and unexpected breakdowns.


Signs You Need a New Transmission

Slipping Gears

  • If your car unexpectedly changes gears or struggles to stay in gear, this is a sign of serious transmission problems.
  • Slipping gears can make driving unpredictable and dangerous.

Delayed or Rough Shifting

  • A healthy transmission should shift smoothly. If you experience hesitation, jerking, or grinding when changing gears, it may indicate internal damage.

Leaking Transmission Fluid

  • A red, brown, or black fluid puddle under your car is a clear sign of a transmission fluid leak.
  • Low transmission fluid can cause overheating and further damage.

Burning Smell

  • Overheating transmission fluid produces a burning smell, signaling that your transmission is struggling due to excessive friction.

Check Engine Light

  • While the check engine light can indicate multiple issues, if it’s accompanied by shifting problems, your transmission might be the culprit.

Noisy Transmission

  • A failing transmission may make whining, buzzing, or clunking sounds, especially when shifting gears.

Complete Transmission Failure

  • If your car won’t go into gear at all or refuses to move, the transmission may be beyond repair.


Repair, Rebuild, or Replace: Which is Best?

Once you identify transmission problems, the next step is deciding whether to repair, rebuild, or replace it.

Transmission Repair

  • Best for minor issues such as fluid leaks, worn-out seals, or sensor malfunctions.
  • Less expensive than a rebuild or replacement.
  • If your transmission has multiple problems, a repair may only provide a temporary fix.

Transmission Rebuild

  • Involves disassembling the transmission, replacing worn-out parts, and reassembling it.
  • Can be a cost-effective alternative to full replacement if the transmission is not severely damaged.
  • Takes longer than a simple repair but may extend the life of your transmission.

Transmission Replacement

  • A brand-new or remanufactured transmission is installed.
  • Best option when the transmission is beyond repair or has extensive internal damage.
  • More expensive upfront but ensures long-term reliability.


When Should You Replace Your Transmission?

Here are some key situations where a full transmission replacement is the best option:

Your Transmission Has Failed Completely

  • If the car won’t move or go into gear at all, replacing the transmission is often the only solution.

Your Car Has High Mileage

  • If your transmission has over 100,000 miles and is experiencing serious issues, replacing it might be more cost-effective than constant repairs.

You’ve Had Multiple Repairs

  • If your transmission has been repaired multiple times but continues to fail, replacing it could save you money in the long run.

Repair Costs Are Too High

  • If the cost of rebuilding or repairing your transmission is close to or higher than the value of your car, replacement (or even getting a new car) may be a better choice.

You Want Long-Term Reliability

  • A new transmission provides peace of mind and eliminates the risk of future breakdowns.
©2025 MISSION TRANSMISSION PARTS